77 79 10 79 44 73 · 5 · 32 72 66 12 92 · 5 · 22 34 · 5 · 10 16 12 17 66 03 71
t u m u l ti [null] in te r n i [null] del la [null] m o n a r chi a
a = 17 71 · e = 13 49 · i = 42 92 · 5 null · 8063 quando · 63 se

Madrid → Rome · homophonic cipher of two-digit figures with a four-digit nomenclator · 13 October 1767

Nuncio Lucini from Madrid to the Secretariat of State, 13 October 1767

Cardinal Torrigiani
toCardinal Torrigiani

Archivio Apostolico Vaticano, Segreteria di Stato, Spagna 304, the leaves ending at f. 280 (DECODE R120). A four-page letter in clear whose last sentence goes into figures. George Lasry’s key for the series had been on the record since 2020, but no decipherment of this passage was found. The key was applied with one value corrected and five code groups added; the sentence decrypts except for one code.

Daniel Bourdeau · posted · updated

Method: read with known key · Extent: complete

Summary. The project catalogue listed DECODE R120 (item 246) as a ciphered letter of “Abbot Vincenti and nuncio Lucini” dated 2 June 1767, with what the cipher hides unknown. That date is the start of the volume. The four imaged pages are one letter of 13 October 1767 from Cesare Alberico Lucini, nuncio in Madrid, and all of it is in clear except the last sentence. George Lasry reconstructed the key for this series in 2020 from a sibling letter (R121) and attached it to both records. But the only decryption on R120 was his text of R121, not of R120’s own figures. With that key, one transcription slip corrected from the image, one key value corrected (63 is se, not di) and five code groups added, the passage decrypts in full except one code. Asked by Charles III’s minister Grimaldi to renew, without limit, the licence to make clergy testify before lay judges in cases of lèse-majesté, the nuncio writes to Rome that the demand aims at i tumulti interni della monarchia and the risings in various places. The sentence runs on to a leaf DECODE did not image.
The foot of a handwritten Italian letter: clear text ending in 'tenda ad estinguere i' followed by six lines of running figures
Spagna 304 f. 280: the clear text breaks into figures after “tenda ad estinguere i”. Image: Archivio Apostolico Vaticano, Segreteria di Stato, Spagna 304 f. 280, via DECODE R120.

01 The letter and the key

Spagna 304 is the second volume of the Madrid nunciature’s original letters and ciphers for June–December 1767. DECODE imaged four pages of it as R120 and one leaf, f. 485 (December 1767), as R121. R120 was transcribed by MEG in June 2020, R121 by EHum in 2017. On 24 October 2020 Lasry posted a reconstructed key and a decryption of R121. He attached both to R120 as well, which may be why R120 is marked “partially decrypted”.

The key is a small nunciature cipher: fixed-length two-digit homophones for letters and common syllables (a 17|71, e 13|49, i 42|92, che 02, non 61, del 22, la 34), the digit 5 as a null, and four-digit nomenclator codes that all begin with 8. No two-digit element begins with 5, so a lone 5 is always the null and the figures divide into units without ambiguity.

02 The ciphered sentence

The 152 figures divide into 82 tokens. Decrypted group by group:

77 79 10 79 44 73 5 32 72 66 12 92 5 22 34 5 10 16 12 17 66 03 71 5 92 8061 42 5 23 8063 5 32 8063 5 67 5
t  u  m  u  l  ti _ in te r  n  i  _ del la _ m  o  n  a  r  chi a  _ i  qual i  _ di quando_ in quando_ si _
20 8700 5 63 12 73 91 49 5 32 8107 49 5 76 16 44 99 13 79 17 8099 42 5 02 5 76 79 09 90 49 11 16 60 5 32 5 23 79 13 66 67 5
f  anno _ se n  ti r  e  _ in [?]  e  _ s  o  l  l  e  v  a  zion i  _ che_ s  u  c  c  e  d  o  no _ in _ di v  e  r  si _
Io credo, che la dimanda che mi si fa tenda ad estinguere i tumulti interni della monarchia, i quali di quando in quando si fanno sentire in [8107] e sollevazioni che succedono in diversi […]

“I believe the request made to me aims at putting down the internal disturbances of the monarchy, which from time to time make themselves felt in [8107], and the risings that break out in various [places] …”

Changes to the key and transcription:

03 What the clear part says

Right after Cardinal Pallavicini, Lucini’s predecessor, had left, the Marqués de Grimaldi, Secretary of State, sent the nuncio a note, which is enclosed with the letter. In the king’s name it asked for the renewal of the licence that Pallavicini had granted on 1 July 1766: the power to make churchmen submit to examination and give evidence before lay judges in cases of lèse-majesté. The king wanted it indefinita ed illimitata, and extended from the regular clergy to the secular clergy.

Lucini first took the licence for a special faculty given to his predecessor “in occasione della nota sollevazione”, the Madrid riots of 1766, which had lapsed with him. Then he read the printed cedula Grimaldi had enclosed and saw that Pallavicini had made the faculty pass to his successors. So he offered the king a renewal with his predecessor’s cautions, which the Pope had approved (letter of 7 August 1766). For the secular clergy he would subdelegate to the bishops, as Pallavicini had done for the diocese of Cuenca (approved 4 September 1766). He does not know whether the king will accept a time-limited renewal, and asks for instructions. The cipher then gives his private view of Madrid’s motive. This was six months after the expulsion of the Jesuits from Spain in April 1767.

04 What remains open

05 Sources

Working files, the corrected figures, the parser and the full reading are in lucini1767/.